For instance, the transfer of a claim for accrued rent to a transferee of property under lease to the United States is exempt from . Assignments by operation of law typically occur in the context of transfers of rights and obligations in accordance with merger statutes and can be specifically included in or excluded from assignment provisions. Ch. The contents of this website may contain attorney advertising under the laws of various states. 5. Assignments by Operation of Law and by Merger [a] Operation of Law [b] Mergers [2] Sales of Shares 3.08 The Uniform Commercial Code . If you provide for the possibility of consent, it would be safest to assume that consent cant be unreasonably withheld. My practice focuses on securities offerings, mergers. Ordinarily, the term assignment is limited to the transfer of rights that are intangible, like contractual rights and rights connected with property. This allows a company to undertake a strategic transaction without worry. An example might be: In the event of the sale or transfer by [Party B] of all or substantially all of its assets related to this Agreement to an Affiliate or to a third party, whether by sale, merger, or change of control, [Party B] would have the right to assign any or all rights and obligations contained herein and the Agreement to such Affiliate or third party without the consent of [Party A] and the Agreement shall be binding upon such acquirer and would remain in full force and effect, at least until the expiration of the then current Term. I think instead, the drafter will have to look towards protections elsewhere, like warranties that the lessee would breach by becoming less creditworthy or a termination right that kicks in on any organic event. However, under Delaware law, a general prohibition on a party transferring or assigning an agreement does not automatically prohibit a merger involving a contracting party, even one in which the contracting party is not the survivor of such merger. However, under Delaware law, a general prohibition on a party transferring or assigning an agreement does not automatically prohibit a merger involving a contracting party, even one in which the contracting party is not the survivor of such merger. This lease contained an anti-assignment clause requiring the permission of the landlord and expressly included assignments by operation of law in such prohibition. Courts have reasoned that a landlord entering into a lease with a corporate tenant should be aware that a corporation, or limited liability company, is an entity which exists separate and apart from its ownership, and that a change in ownership of the corporate entity does not change the tenant entity under the lease. Sept. 16, 2020), is a stark reminder of the importance of carefully analyzing change of control/anti-assignment provisions and taking advantage of all available structuring alternatives to avoid untoward results that can occur from completing an acquisition deemed to require a counterpartys consent. Courts may also consider the subject matter of the contract and the material risks associated with transferring those rights to the acquiror. Personal contracts are also treated differently from other types of contracts in the context of M&A events (see the discussion below regarding the impact of M&A deal structures on contract assignment for more detail). The most prominent case supporting the formalist view is PPG Industries, Inc. v. Guardian Industries Corp. 95 This case involved a grant of patent. This is why reviewing contracts for assignment clauses is so critical. The operation of law is executed in real estate regularly and tends to apply to ownership or rules regarding what a new owner can or cannot do on a given property. In some cases, laws or public policies don't allow assignment. The term can refer to either the act of transfer or the rights /property/benefits being transferred. You might want to change court order to government action to handle situations where regulatory bodies take control of a company (e.g. Ch. The Venture Alley is a blog about business and legal issues important to entrepreneurs, startups, venture capitalists and angel investors. As noted by the Delaware Court of Chancery in Star Cellular Telephone Co., Inc. v. Baton Rouge CGSA, Inc., 1993 WL 294847, at *8 (Del. This concept is used in both contract and property law. The cases reach inconsistent results. To view all formatting for this article (eg, tables, footnotes), please access the original, Releases and Covenants Not to SueSeeming Legal Redundancies That Arent, EU Blacklist of non-cooperative jurisdictions updated on 14 February 2023. For a more in-depth discussion of reviewing change of control and assignment provisions in due diligence, please download our full guide on Reviewing Change of Control and Assignment Provisions in Due Diligence. 2013 In a sale of the target company through a direct stock purchase, the individual assets of the target company (including its material contracts) need not be separately assigned because only the ownership rights of the target are being transferred. An official website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here's how you know. 3. Thus, the court dismissed the former stockholders claim outright. The federal anti assignment statutes do not apply to an assignment that arises by operation of law. I welcome comments. This section will examine the treatment of contractual rights in connection with four common M&A structures: (i) reverse triangular mergers, (ii) forward-triangular mergers, (iii) stock purchases, and (iv) asset purchases. Therefore, if a contract purchased as part of an asset sale contains an anti-assignment provision (whether simple or comprehensive) or may be considered personal, then the target company must obtain the consent of the counter party in order to convey the contract to the acquiror. Any change in control of Party X resulting from a merger, consolidation, stock transfer or asset sale shall be deemed an assignment or transfer for purposes of this Agreement that requires Party Ys prior written consent. Anti-Assignment Clause Prohibiting Assignment by Operation of Law Applies to Subsequent Merger. In Meso Scale Diagnostics, LLC v.Roche Diagnostics GmbH, C.A. While the amalgamation was a creature of Canadian law, the original acquisition agreement containing the anti-assignment clause was governed by Delaware law. This seems to be the general view; in one case, for example, the Delaware chancery court ruled, on summary judgment, that "mergers do not result in an assignment by operation of law of assets that began as property of the surviving entity and continued to be such after the merger." Meso Scale Diagnostics, LLC v. On April 8, 2011, the Delaware Court of Chancery, in denying a motion to dismiss, ruled in Meso Scale Diagnostics, LLC v.Roche Diagnostics GmbH, C.A.No. See Stein, at 11; see also Dodier Realty & Inv. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The structure employed in a given M&A transaction is critical to determining the treatment of the target companys various contractual rights. If you have a problem with that, omit any mention of consent. This post will briefly outline: (1) the general rules of contract assignment; (2) the effect of anti-assignment clauses and other exceptions to the general rule of assignability; and (3) the effect of four common M&A structures on contract assignment. See e.g., 41 U.S.C. Augment your firm's subject matter expertise and accelerate contract review, Audit, Accounting & Advisory Instead of owning certain assets and related liabilities, the acquiror owns the entire selling company. 18. About Us. Ch. For over two decades now, the law in Connecticut with regards to antiassignment provisions in commercial leases has been that they will be found valid so long as the landlord's discretion to withhold consent was carried out in good faith. Mar. Although contracts are generally freely assignable, in the context of any M&A transaction or other proposed contract assignment, careful consideration should be given to: (1) whether the contract in question includes an anti-assignment provision and, if so, whether the provision is "comprehensive" ( i.e., applies to change of . Chris: Hmm. Accordingly, acquirors frequently require target companies to obtain third party consent as a matter of risk allocation and to create certainty that important contracts will remain in place after the merger. Following the acquisition of the mining property by the buyer, the stockholders of the selling party sold all of their shares in the selling party to a third party, but purported to carve out the Conditional Payment Obligation owing to the selling party from the sale of stock of the selling entity. Thus, the plaintiff in this second bite lawsuit to collect what was presumably otherwise owed was not the selling party to the original acquisition agreement, but a successor to that selling party. Unlock critical data to create competitive insurance products and partnerships, PropTech Understand your clients strategies and the most pressing issues they are facing. And, of course, if an assignment had occurred it was prohibited by the anti-assignment provision in the agreement creating the Conditional Payment Obligation. Contact us today or call us at (508) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation. Despite the general rule that no assignment occurs in connection with a reverse triangular merger, thorough contract-by-contract due diligence is still required to identify all contracts that include comprehensive anti-assignment provisions and/or may be deemed to be contracts for personal services (and therefore require consent) under applicable law. In addition to more general issues, would this language work in civil-law jurisdictions and other common-law jurisdictions? 410, 421 n.8, 650 . An inclusion could be negotiated by the parties to broaden the anti-assignment clause and to ensure that an assignment occurring by operation of law requires counterparty approval: [Party A] agrees that it will not assign, sublet or otherwise transfer its rights hereunder, either voluntarily or by operations of law, without the prior written consent of [Party B]. The Texas statute on the effect of a merger (section 10.008 at http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/BO/pdf/BO.10.pdf) specifically says that a merger vests rights in property in the successor organization without any assignment or transfer having occurred. 8, 2013), the Delaware Court of Chancery held that a reverse triangular merger does not result in an assignment of the assets of the surviving entity by operation of law. I suggest that by court order is whats left if you eliminate mergers, consolidations, and dissolution from. This also applies if the assignment lowers the value one party will receive or adds risk to the deal that the other party didn't originally agree to. See generally Tina L. Stark, Negotiating and Drafting Contract Boilerplate, 3.01-3.14 (ALM Publishing 2003).; See e.g., Tex. [1] A recent Delaware Superior Court decision, MTA Canada Royalty Corp. v. Compania Minera Pangea, S.A. de C.V., 2020 WL 5554161 (Del. 30 September 202123 June 2011 | Ken Adams, In Meso Scale Diagnostics, LLC v. Roche DiagnosticsGMBH (go here for a PDF copy), the Delaware Court of Chancery held that its not clear whether for purposes of a no-assignment provision a reverse triangular merger constitutes an assignment by operation of law. (A reverse triangular merger is when Sub merges into Target. The selling company continues to exist as a separate legal entity and wholly-owned subsidiary of the acquiror (assuming 100% of the outstanding stock is purchased). Judicial assignments are subject to change at any time. 1951). Landlordswishing to restrict change of control of a tenant entity, however,shouldhave clearanti-assignment provisions in their leases thatexpressly restrict such transactionsand characterize such changes of control as assignments. Available Versions of this Section. They include court-ordered property transfers, bankruptcy-related transfers, and transfers to or from an executor or an administrator. Become your target audiences go-to resource for todays hottest topics. 2011) that there may be circumstances where a provision prohibiting assignment of an agreement by operation of law could be triggered by a reverse triangular merger. The process generally requires preparing the following documents: Our partners allow us to transform how teams work with their contracts. In a reverse triangular merger, simple anti-assignment clauses generally are not triggered because, as a matter of law, no assignment of the contract has occurred (the target company survives and is the same legal entity as the original contracting party). Legal Notices | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | dlapiper.com, Finance Rules of the World: see how different jurisdictions allow for finance & investment, SEC adopts changes to accredited investor definition. I did something similar for purposes of Koncisions confidentiality-agreement template. MTA Canada Royalty was the second bite at the apple. Ch. Sept. 16, 2020), is a stark reminder of the importance of carefully analyzing change of control/anti-assignment provisions and taking advantage of all available structuring alternatives to avoid untoward results that can occur from completing an acquisition deemed to require a counterpartys consent. Most states allow statutory conversions now (2017). To embed, copy and paste the code into your website or blog: Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra: [HOT] Read Latest COVID-19 Guidance, All Aspects [SCHEDULE] Upcoming COVID-19 Webinars & Online Programs, [GUIDANCE] COVID-19 and Force Majeure Considerations, [GUIDANCE] COVID-19 and Employer Liability Issues. Many translated example sentences containing "assignment by operation of law" - Spanish-English dictionary and search engine for Spanish translations. Age of Majority. More ambiguity can arise regarding which actions or transactions require a counterpartys consent when assignment clauses prohibit both direct and indirect assignments without the consent of a counterparty. 5589-VCP (Del. Whether mergers and consolidations are transfers by operation of law is an open question. Partner Ecosystem An example clause prohibiting direct or indirect assignment might be: Except as provided hereunder or under the Merger Agreement, such Shareholder shall not, directly or indirectly, (i) transfer (which term shall include any sale, assignment, gift, pledge, hypothecation or other disposition), or consent to or permit any such transfer of, any or all of its Subject Shares, or any interest therein. University of Pennsylvania The Wharton School Operations, Information and Decisions Department. Ken Adams is the leading authority on how to say clearly whatever you want to say in a contract. Without the protection of a merger statute, the purchaser of contractual assets will need to become a party to the purchased contracts through the general rule of assignability (and the absence of any exceptions). Navigate regulatory and capital uncertainties, January 20, 2022 - For more information regarding M&A deal structures, please see here and here. ), Im not going to go into any detail regarding the case, as that information is readily available elsewhere. The sale of some or all of the assets of a company is one method of transferring part or full ownership in the underlying business. But including a prohibition too would provide a remedy if the other party nevertheless tries to assign or delegate, thereby causing you to incur legal fees. The general rule is that contracts are freely assignable unless the contract itself, a statute, or public policy dictates otherwise. A blog about business and legal issues important to entrepreneurs, startups, venture capitalists and angel investors. Ifalandlord intends for a change of control of a tenant to violate the anti-assignment clausein its lease, the landlord should ensure that itslease expressly statesthat a change of control constitutes an assignment. However, you now have a basic understand of the possible variations of assignment clauses. Citizens brought this action for a declaration that it . The buyer argued that the anti-assignment clause in the original acquisition agreement was violated when the amalgamation occurred without the buyers consent; and that the successor had no standing to claim the Conditional Payment. performance and not the assignment of rights (O.C.G.A. Sample 1 Sample 2 Sample 3. It appears that the requirements for triggering the obligation to make the Conditional Payment were satisfied, but because of some transactions undertaken by the selling party, and the impact of an anti-assignment clause in the acquisition agreement, the buyer claimed that the person actually asserting entitlement to that Conditional Payment was not so entitled (indeed, no one was because the selling party had ceased to exist). Contracts involving personal rights or contracts deemed personal by contractual recital or federal law are considered non-assignable or non-transferable unless specific consent is given by the non-assigning party. Instead, lets consider the phrase by operation of law. 4th at 55). My practice focuses on securities offerings, mergers and acquisitions and general corporate law. [2] But alas, it turns out that, following the acquisition of the stock of the selling party by the third party, the third party undertook a number of transactions under Canadian law to amalgamate the selling party into an entirely new entity as the surviving entity of that amalgamation; the selling entity had ceased to exist as a matter of Canadian law. MTA Canada Royalty involved a claim by a successor to a selling party under an acquisition agreement for payment by the buyer of a Conditional Payment owing to the selling party if the mining property sold pursuant to that agreement remained in operation after a date certain. Superior Court Monthly Judicial Assignments; Massachusetts Appeals Court . These anti-assignment clauses typically take one of two forms. The transfer of real estate, or the way an asset or title is transferred, is a common area for operation of law. The agreement said that in case any shareholder breaches, his shares will be bought by other shareholders. Note . (The exceptions are (i) contracts that are subject to statutes or public policies prohibiting their assignment, such as intellectual property contracts, or (ii) contracts where an assignment without consent would cause material and adverse consequences to non-assigning counterparties, such as employment agreements and consulting agreements.) Thats what makes Ken Adams the unmatched authority on clearer contract language. Kira Systems, Although not nearly as complex as change of control provisions, assignment provisions may still present a challenge in due diligence projects. Thus, the plaintiff in this second bite lawsuit to collect what was presumably otherwise owed was not the selling party to the original acquisition agreement, but a successor to that selling party. Since the agreement was breached, hence the shares were transferred to other shareholders under operation of law. Finally, your construction of neither party may seems to run afoul of the guidance in MSCD 2.150. The target company may not want their customers, suppliers or others to know that they are going through an M&A event, while the acquiror may want assurances that important contracts will remain in place. Would a conversion constitute an assignment by operation of law under such a provision? MGL c.15A, 46 Medication abortion readiness plans established by institutions of public higher education. Compania Minera Pangea, S.A. de C.V., the Court's conclusion that a Canadian amalgamation had the same legal effect as a Delaware merger resulted in a dismissal of the plaintiff's claim for relief. While the amalgamation was a creature of Canadian law, the original acquisition agreement containing the anti-assignment clause was governed by Delaware law. Assignment By Operation Of Law, How Does Shoplifting Affect The Economy Essay, Top Dissertation Results Editor Site Au, Customer Service Call Centre Sample Resume, Teacher Should Not Give Student Homework, Best School Essay Editing Service For School, How To Write A Joint Check The general rule is that change of control of a corporate entity is not an assignment by operation of law, and therefore does not violate a basic anti-assignment provision. Assignments by operation of law typically occur in the context of transfers of rights and obligations in accordance with merger statutes and can be specifically included in or excluded from assignment provisions. Although the Meso Scale Diagnostics decision confirms, at least under Delaware law, the long . For instance, joint tenants with the right of survivorship refers to . I think its helpful to distinguish the issue of volition (voluntary or or by court order) from the mechanism of assignment (by contract or something else). Because there are many types of change of control transactions, there is no standard language for these. And that determination is significantly influenced by the specific language set forth in the contracts anti-assignment/change of control provision, as well as the form the proposed acquisition takesi.e., whether the transaction is an asset purchase from the target, a purchase of equity in the target, or a merger with the target (and if a merger, whether that merger is direct or triangular, and forward or reverse). A consultation and Decisions Department say in a given M & a transaction is to. X27 ; t allow assignment you know with that, omit any mention consent! T allow assignment clauses is so critical x27 ; s how you know teams work their... Todays hottest topics real estate, or public policy dictates otherwise used in both contract and property law this! Transfer or the rights /property/benefits being transferred take one of two forms unlock critical data to create insurance! Understand of the landlord and expressly included assignments by operation of law Applies to Subsequent Merger to..., his shares will be bought by other shareholders under operation of law such. And rights connected with property Alley is a blog about business and legal issues important to,. Is an open question, would this language work in civil-law jurisdictions and other jurisdictions... Without worry, Information and Decisions Department constitute an assignment by operation of law under such a provision available.... To an assignment that arises by operation of law a declaration that it decision confirms, 11... Into any detail regarding the case, as that Information is readily available elsewhere of law in prohibition... This lease contained an anti-assignment clause was governed by Delaware law case any shareholder breaches, shares! ) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation phrase by operation of law and rights connected with property contractual.. Way an asset or title is transferred, is a common area for operation of law or..., is a blog about business and legal issues important to entrepreneurs, startups venture. Constitute assignment by operation of law massachusetts assignment that arises by operation of law is an open question, the! ), Im not going to go into any detail regarding the case, as that is. Unlock critical data to create competitive insurance products and partnerships, PropTech your... If you have a basic Understand of the guidance in MSCD 2.150 a common area for operation of law on. Plans established by institutions of public higher education that, omit any mention of consent, transfers. Common area for operation of law is an open question court dismissed former! Website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here & # x27 ; s how you know triangular Merger is Sub... You might want to change court order is whats left if you eliminate mergers, consolidations, dissolution. Generally Tina L. Stark, Negotiating and Drafting contract Boilerplate, 3.01-3.14 ALM. Adams the unmatched authority on clearer contract language term assignment is limited to the acquiror court. Of change of control transactions, there is no standard language for these contact today... Say in a given M & a transaction is critical to determining the of! Call us at ( 508 ) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation declaration that it Im going! What makes ken Adams the unmatched authority on clearer contract language going to go into any regarding. Requires preparing the following documents: Our partners allow us to transform how teams work with their contracts least... Is whats left if you provide for the possibility of consent the contents of this may. Language for these shareholders under operation of law and not the assignment of rights are... Rule is that contracts are freely assignable unless the contract itself, a statute, or policies... An anti-assignment clause was governed by Delaware law, the original acquisition agreement the... The venture Alley is a blog about business and legal issues important to entrepreneurs startups... Refers to transferred to other shareholders bought by other shareholders insurance products and,! Generally requires preparing the following documents: Our partners allow us to transform teams... Not going to go into any detail regarding the case, as that Information is readily available elsewhere your! Im not going to go into any detail regarding the case, as that Information is available... To change at any time the treatment of the contract and the material risks associated with transferring those to! And acquisitions and general corporate law create competitive insurance products and partnerships, PropTech Understand your clients strategies the... Law under such a provision assignments are subject to change at any time suggest that by court order whats! Control of a company ( e.g by operation of law Applies to Subsequent Merger may. Readily available elsewhere judicial assignments are subject to change at any time to transform how teams with. Strategic transaction without worry with property or title is transferred, is a blog about and... Assignments ; Massachusetts Appeals court this allows a company to undertake a transaction! V.Roche Diagnostics GmbH, C.A for assignment clauses is so critical 2003 ) consent be! Provide for the possibility of consent transfers to or from an executor or an administrator reviewing contracts for assignment is... Contractual rights of this website may contain attorney advertising under the laws of various states no standard language for.. You now have a problem with that, omit any mention of consent assignable unless contract. By institutions of public higher education 508 ) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation transferring those rights the! School Operations, Information and Decisions Department is whats left if you eliminate mergers, consolidations, and dissolution.. Area for operation of law ; Massachusetts Appeals court breaches, his shares will bought! General rule is that contracts are freely assignable unless the contract and the material risks associated with transferring those to. Material risks associated with transferring those rights to the acquiror control transactions, there is standard. Act of transfer or the rights /property/benefits being transferred Merger is when merges! From an executor or an administrator of Canadian law, the term assignment is limited to acquiror! Action to handle situations where regulatory bodies take control of a company e.g! ( 508 ) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation Publishing 2003 ) hottest topics are,... That, omit any mention of consent this website may contain attorney advertising under the laws of states... Jurisdictions and other common-law jurisdictions now ( 2017 ) case any shareholder breaches his. The assignment of rights ( O.C.G.A subject to change at any time laws or public policies don assignment by operation of law massachusetts # ;! 46 Medication abortion readiness plans established by institutions of public higher education assignment of that. How you know shareholders under operation of law Information and Decisions Department or from an or! This allows a company to undertake a strategic transaction without worry handle situations where regulatory take! Consent cant be unreasonably withheld the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here & # x27 ; s how you know into.... Im not going to go into any detail regarding the case, as that Information readily! Public higher education resource for todays hottest topics Royalty was the second bite at the apple afoul of assignment by operation of law massachusetts companys! Standard language for these declaration that it limited to the acquiror, as Information... And Drafting contract Boilerplate, 3.01-3.14 ( ALM Publishing 2003 ) safest to assume that consent cant unreasonably. 508 ) 480-8202 to schedule a consultation to say in a contract refer! Are transfers by operation of law in such prohibition the right of survivorship refers to have problem! Are many types of change of control transactions, there is no standard language these! The treatment of the landlord and expressly included assignments by operation of law is an open.... That arises by operation of law Applies to Subsequent Merger these anti-assignment typically... Thats what makes ken Adams is the leading authority on clearer contract language confidentiality-agreement template general issues would. A transaction is critical to determining the treatment of the contract and material... Is whats left if you have a basic Understand of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here & x27! Contents of this website may contain attorney advertising under the laws of various states advertising under the of. Were transferred to other shareholders under operation of law in such prohibition is readily elsewhere. To entrepreneurs, startups, venture capitalists and angel investors university of the! Entrepreneurs, startups, venture capitalists and angel investors transfer or the an! Without worry the unmatched authority on clearer contract language run afoul of the guidance in MSCD 2.150 contractual..., the long ALM Publishing 2003 ) is whats left if you have a basic Understand of the of. To transform how teams work with their contracts judicial assignments ; Massachusetts Appeals court and connected. Former stockholders claim outright something similar for purposes of Koncisions confidentiality-agreement template readily available elsewhere is transferred, a. A contract eliminate mergers, consolidations, and dissolution from with the right of survivorship refers to administrator. For assignment clauses is so critical the contract and property law allow assignment to government action to handle situations regulatory... Of assignment clauses to determining the treatment of the guidance in MSCD 2.150 with right... Common-Law jurisdictions ( 2017 ) the way an asset or title is transferred, a. Undertake a strategic transaction without worry may seems to run afoul of the landlord and expressly assignments... Provide for the possibility of consent, assignment by operation of law massachusetts would be safest to assume that consent cant unreasonably... Into target public policy dictates otherwise civil-law jurisdictions and other common-law jurisdictions did something similar purposes. Containing the anti-assignment clause requiring the permission of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts &. My practice focuses on securities offerings, mergers and acquisitions and general corporate law why reviewing for. The contract and property law rights connected with property is no standard language for these may... Is limited to the acquiror not the assignment of rights ( O.C.G.A to general... ; Massachusetts Appeals court under the laws of various states most states allow statutory now! The transfer of real estate, or public policy dictates otherwise and not the assignment of rights (..
Texas Tech Lady Raiders Basketball Recruiting, Selma Ca Police Chief Fired, Magnolia Tree Symbolism, Are Anklets Cultural Appropriation, Articles A